Questions to Ask Before Marriage: Our Values Conversation, 10 Years In
Ten years married and still split on honesty, we asked each other seven values questions on camera. Here's what came up, from peace and respect to an $8 cupcake, plus a quick check to try with your own person.
Ten years married and still split on honesty, queer interracial couple Jill and Lori Young walk through seven values questions every couple should ask before marriage.
TL;DR The values conversation is the first of The 12 Conversations we use in premarital mentoring, and it's the first one we had with each other before we married. This post shares the seven values questions we asked each other on the podcast, what came up for us ten years in, and a quick check you can do with your own person.
We've been married ten years, and we still don't agree on honesty. That's one reason the values conversation sits at the top of our list of questions to ask before marriage.
Lori was raised on "honesty is the best policy" and still lives by it. Jill believes honesty has gray areas, and that nobody needs to tell new parents their baby looks a little like an alien. We rediscovered this while recording the episode and laughed about it, because by now we both know where each of us learned our version of the truth.
Values are the foundation of who we are. They guide almost every decision we make, and when you trace an argument between two people back far enough, there's usually a value sitting at the bottom of it. Knowing your own values, knowing your partner's, and knowing where you line up and where you don't is some of the best preparation for marriage we know of.
So this episode of Love in Full Color kicks off a new series called The 12 Conversations. These are the conversations we had with each other before we decided to get married, and they're the framework behind the premarital mentoring we do with couples now. We start with values on purpose.
Below are the seven questions we asked each other, what came up for us, and a quick check you can do together. Pick two or three of the questions and try them over dinner this week.
The Seven Values Questions We Asked Each Other
These are the questions from the episode. You don't need to answer all of them in one sitting, and you definitely don't need to agree on the answers.
- What's a value you didn't know you had until we started building a life together?
- What's one value you would never compromise on?
- What's a value you brought with you from the way you were raised, and what's one you left behind?
- Where do our values line up the most, and where are they furthest apart?
- Has one of your values changed since we got married?
- What's a value you see in me that you admire?
- What do you hope people see about our values when they look at our marriage?
Here's how they went for us.
The Value You Didn't Know You Had
For Jill, it was peace. For Lori, it was authenticity. Neither of us would have put those at the top of the list in our twenties.
Jill has always valued loyalty, commitment, trustworthiness, hard work and, at the core of everything, being a really good person. Peace wasn't on that list when she was young, and she could handle a certain amount of drama back then. Once she was in a serious, committed relationship later in life, peace went straight to the top, because without it the other values start to slip. In her words, "We could work through the communication part if we were being peaceful." When there's no peace, she starts compromising, and compromise is where mistrust and dishonesty creep in.
Peace also changed what loyalty means to her. Jill grew up in a neighborhood where loyalty meant everything, and you rode or died with your people. She's been loyal to a fault, letting people get away with things and putting her own needs aside. Then at some point you ask yourself whether you really want to ride with that guy and possibly die. Now her loyalty comes with boundaries. If trouble comes to us, we ride together. If someone keeps showing up at the door with trouble, they may need to ride by themselves.
Lori's answer came from somewhere else. She spent most of her life trying to please everyone, and she still catches herself doing it. She thought she was living an authentic life, and it wasn't working for her. When we met, our relationship felt easy and real in a way nothing before it had, and she was done living for other people.
Jill has a saying, "I'm not for everybody," and she means it. Watching Jill live that way helped Lori stop worrying so much about what other people think. When you're fully yourself, you'll lose some people. The ones who love you for who you are will be right there waiting on you.
The Value We'd Never Compromise On
For Jill, it's respect. For Lori, it's inclusivity. These are our hot buttons, and it was a little funny to realize on camera how tied together they are.
Lori answered this one for Jill before Jill could, and she nailed it. Jill is generous and caring and would give the world to the people she loves, but disrespect is a trigger for her. She traces it back to watching her parents, especially her dad, and then to growing up as a Black person in a country where so many people will disrespect or discount you. "If I don't have respect anywhere else, I'm going to have respect in my house." She'll walk away from a job or a situation where she's being disrespected, and Lori has watched her do it. Knowing why respect runs so deep for Jill is part of how Lori respects it.
Lori gets fired up about inclusivity, and that comes from being excluded over and over, from grade school all the way to today. When she came out as a gay woman, an aunt told her she was going to hell. Hearing what people have said to her older son, and hearing how Jill has been treated over the years, only sharpened it.
We can hold different opinions and viewpoints and still be kind to each other. What Lori can't make sense of is cruelty that hides behind "that's just my opinion." Being mean to someone because they're gay is not just an opinion.
What We Kept From How We Were Raised, and What We Left Behind
We both grew up in homes where a lot went unsaid. We both decided our kids would get something different.
The value Jill left behind was privacy. She was raised by older parents who grew up during the Depression, in a generation not far removed from slavery and living through segregation and Jim Crow. Keeping your business inside the house made sense for them. Nobody talked with Jill about relationships or growing up or how she was feeling, so she worked those things out on her own. It didn't harm her, but when she had kids, she wanted them to feel safe telling her things. If she's stressed and never says why, her kids see the stress without knowing the reason. She'll be the first to tell you she wasn't perfect at it, and she kept trying.
Lori grew up the same way. She didn't know much about her parents' lives, and she wasn't allowed to express feelings, especially the hard ones. She also never heard an apology. Not once. So she made herself a promise that when she got it wrong with her kids, kindness and love would rule over pride. If she lost her temper, she'd come back and say, "I'm sorry. I think I lost my temper."
Why "I'm Sorry" Feels So Risky
For a lot of parents, apologizing feels like giving up authority. We came at that fear from opposite sides.
Jill was honest about her side of it. She worried that if she admitted she was wrong, her kids would stop respecting her, and she wouldn't be able to correct them again. Respect is her hot button, so of course that's where the fear landed. Lori felt the opposite. To her, respect is earned, and owning your mistakes is how you earn it. If she didn't apologize, she figured her kids wouldn't respect her at all.
We also talked about the pedestal. Kids put their parents up there, so when a parent hurts them and never says sorry, the kid decides something must be wrong with them. Meanwhile the parent was probably tired, worried about bills and doing the best they could. Both sides suffer. Part of getting older is realizing your parents were human.
Apologizing takes vulnerability, and Lori was the first person to tell Jill that vulnerability is strength. Plenty of families teach the opposite, and in some neighborhoods being vulnerable really does make you a mark. We understand why so many people find "I'm sorry" hard to say.
Where Our Values Line Up, and Where They Don't
We share far more values than we don't. Otherwise we wouldn't be celebrating ten years of marriage. The big exception is honesty.
The list where we line up is long. Family, loyalty, commitment, communication, connection and partnership are on it, along with hard work and having fun. We both love having people over and hosting, we're both in the gym every week and eating right, and we even agree on keeping a clean, organized home.
Family got its own moment, because Jill climbed onto her soapbox and looked straight into the camera for it. Once you're married, you are the family. Your parents and siblings matter, and you've known them since day one, but the two of you are the nucleus now. Couples who keep putting their parents' and siblings' opinions first often forget that.
Honesty: Black and White or Gray?
Lori sees honesty in black and white. Jill sees gray. We agree that the trouble really starts when you tell a lie to cover a lie.
Lori's mom drilled "honesty is the best policy" into her head. As a kid, Lori got in more trouble for lying than for whatever she'd actually done, and she was scared to death to lie. So she tells the truth, even when it's hard, and works at delivering it kindly. She also draws a line between withholding and lying. Choosing not to say something isn't dishonest. If you ask her something she doesn't want to answer, she'll tell you she's not comfortable talking about it, or you'll get the kindest version of the truth she can find.
Jill thinks Lori sometimes sugarcoats things so much that people miss the point, and that being direct is a kindness of its own. Then there's the baby. Some newborns look a little like a baby alien, or a baby monkey, or a tiny bear. If Jill told the parents their baby wasn't that cute, it would be a problem. So she says nothing, or something like, "They're so little."
Jill's gray has a bigger reason behind it, too. Our systems tend to punish Black and brown people more harshly for their mistakes than white people. The truth will set you free, or it'll get you killed, or put you in jail. People sometimes lie to protect themselves, because the truth wouldn't help them. Her dad had a saying about the other kind of person: some people will lie even when the truth would help. Those are the ones who end up with a snowball of lies.
Ten years in, we haven't settled who's right. Jill agrees that honesty is the best policy, as long as you know when and how to use it. Lori has started asking whether some of the rules she followed as the "good girl" were ever the right rules.
How a Value Changes After You Get Married
Neither of us changed our values about money. We loosened our grip on them and met in the middle.
Jill has always valued financial responsibility. Her parents were Black and raised during the Depression, when every dime mattered. They did well in life, but they never forgot they could be broke again, and they passed that feeling on. So Jill can catch herself asking whether she really needs new shoes, or doing the math on an $8 cupcake in another country (that's about a quarter's worth of flour). What's relaxed for her is knowing money can also bring happiness, an experience or something beautiful.
Lori used to spend money on random stuff she didn't need. When she got divorced in 2013, she took the credit card debt with her, and filing for bankruptcy was the reset that let her start over in California. After that she got almost rigid about spending. Jill sometimes has to nudge her: babe, we can afford that, and yes, it's okay to spend five dollars on toothpaste. That one's an inside joke now.
Credit cards were a real conversation for us. Jill uses hers for points that pay for our travel and pays it off every month. Early on, we agreed we'd never charge more than we can pay off. We did take a 0% car loan over five years, because the numbers made sense. Each of us moved toward the middle, and we've done well together financially because of it.
The Values We Admire in Each Other
Jill admires Lori's kindness. Lori admires Jill's generosity. Both come with a little teasing.
Jill says Lori always defaults to kindness and treats her heart very carefully, making sure her needs are met. Lori is so kind, in fact, that she can deliver a complaint so nicely that Jill isn't sure she's complaining at all.
Lori says Jill is one of the most generous people she's ever met, with her time, her heart and her actions. She's the one who says, "We should get so-and-so a gift," and she comes home from Costco with things she knows Lori will love. It's also why Lori is protective of her. For years, people mistook Jill's generosity for foolishness and took advantage of it, until she decided they no longer deserved that access to her.
When we first started dating, one of the first things Jill said was that she wanted a partnership, with someone who would worry about her as much as she worried about them. That kind of reciprocity is how we've gotten this far. And for the record, Lori is thoughtful too. She doesn't always think of the gift first, but once it's said, she's a thousand percent on it. (A thousand percent is Lori's favorite saying. One hundred is never enough.)
What We Hope People See in Our Marriage
Love, and a commitment that rides it out until the wheels fall off.
Early in our dating, maybe six months in, we were at a gas station. Jill was pumping gas, and we were holding each other and kissing. A woman who was living on the street walked by and said she wished she had a camera so she could take a picture, because that was the picture of love. Lori has never forgotten it. Love is at the root of everything she does, and it's what she hopes people say when they talk about us.
Jill calls herself more of a head responder than a heart responder. Love, absolutely. She also wants people to know we're committed. Whatever hard times come, we'll stay committed to each other and to this marriage until our last breath. In her words, we're going to ride this till the wheels fall off. If you heard episode one, you know where that line came from.
Quick Check: Your Values Conversation
Answer these on your own, then compare.
A few no answers are normal, even for couples who've been together for years. Each one is a good place to start talking.
What Happens When Couples Skip the Values Conversation
The argument usually shows up looking like something else: money, family, how you spend a Saturday. Underneath, there's often a value nobody has named.
When you don't know each other's values, you end up fighting about the surface. A couple who has never talked about respect may not understand why one partner leaves the room over a tone of voice. A couple who has never compared money stories can turn a five-dollar tube of toothpaste into a standoff. And for someone like Jill, a relationship without peace slowly wears down every other value she holds, until trust starts to go too.
Knowing where a value comes from changes how you hear your partner. Lori knows why respect runs so deep for Jill, so she can honor it rather than take it personally. Jill knows why exclusion lights Lori up, so she doesn't mistake that fire for overreacting. That understanding doesn't make every disagreement go away. It does mean you spend less time guessing, and more time on the same side.
Frequently Asked Questions About Values and Marriage
What values questions should couples ask before marriage?
Start with the seven we asked each other: a value you didn't know you had, one you'd never compromise on, what you kept and left behind from childhood, where your values line up and differ, whether a value has changed, what you admire in each other, and what you hope people see in your marriage. You don't need to cover them all at once. Pick two or three, and ask where each answer came from, because the story behind a value is where most of the understanding happens.
Why are shared values important in a marriage?
Values guide most of the decisions you'll make together, from money to how you treat each other's people. When you trace an argument back far enough, there's usually a value underneath it. Sharing values won't stop you from disagreeing, but it gives you the same foundation to work from when you do. We share most of ours, and it's a big part of why we're ten years in and still choosing each other.
What if my partner and I have different values?
Different values don't automatically mean you're wrong for each other. We still see honesty differently after ten years. What matters is understanding where each value comes from and agreeing on how you'll handle the places you differ. Pay closest attention to the values neither of you will compromise on, like respect for Jill and inclusivity for Lori. If those clash, talk it through before you marry.
How should couples talk about money values before marriage?
Start with the money stories you each grew up with, then talk about how you spend now. Jill's parents were raised during the Depression and taught her that every dime mattered. Lori went through a bankruptcy after her divorce and became almost rigid about spending. Once we understood those stories, we could make simple agreements together, like never charging more than we can pay off each month, and we each moved toward the middle.
Is it dishonest to withhold something from your partner?
Not necessarily. Lori, who sees honesty in black and white, still draws a line between withholding and lying, because choosing not to say something isn't the same as saying something false. What matters is agreeing as a couple on what each of you expects to be told. Some couples want everything shared, and others are comfortable with more privacy. Talk it through so neither of you is working from assumptions.
How do interracial and queer couples handle values shaped by different upbringings?
Talk about where each value came from, including the parts shaped by race, culture and identity. Jill's views on respect and honesty were shaped by growing up Black in a country whose systems punish Black and brown people more harshly. Lori's commitment to inclusivity comes from being excluded, including when she came out. When you understand the history behind a value, you can respect it, even in the places where you'd see things differently yourself.
What are The 12 Conversations?
The 12 Conversations are the topics we talked through with each other before we got married, and they're the framework behind our premarital mentoring at Jillori. The values conversation comes first because values sit underneath everything else. On Love in Full Color, we're walking through all twelve as a couple, one episode at a time. Next up is the differences conversation.
Do we need to be engaged to have these conversations?
No. These conversations help any couple, whether you're engaged, not engaged yet or already married. Some of the best ones happen before anyone proposes, because they help you see what you're building together. We've been married ten years, and we still learned something new about each other while recording this episode.
What's Next?
If this got the two of you talking, the rest of The 12 Conversations will too. We Prepare You is our premarital mentoring experience, with all 12 Conversations and four 60-minute online sessions with Lori. If you'd also like us to officiate your wedding, We Prepare You, Then We Marry You brings both together, from the first conversation all the way to the ceremony.
Learn more at jillori.com.
Want every new episode in your inbox? Join our newsletter at jillori.com. Next week, we get into the differences conversation, because yes, we're very much in love, and we're also very different.
About Jill and Lori Young
Jill and Lori Young have been together for twelve years and married for ten. Through Jillori, they officiate weddings and mentor couples before they marry, with a focus on couples marrying across race, culture and identity. Based in Temecula, California, they serve couples across San Diego, Riverside, Orange and Los Angeles counties, and they host the Love in Full Color podcast. Join their newsletter at jillori.com.